Talk by Prof. Dr. Carsten Ruhl at the Weißenhof-Symposium 2026 „99 Jahre Weißenhof – Moderne und kein Ende?“, State Academy of Fine Arts, Stuttgart
Contrary to the view that still prevails today, the 1927 Werkbund Exhibition in Stuttgart was fiercely criticized not only by conservative circles but also by the left. This applies in particular to the Frankfurt School. The architect and critic Siegfried Kracauer had made no secret of his scepticism in several newspaper articles written during the exhibition itself. Unlike many of his contemporaries, he did not regard the Neues Bauen as a historically unique culmination, but merely as a transitional space. Even Kracauer, however, could not answer the question of what exactly awaited at the end of this passage. Understanding modernity as a passage did, however, allow him to relativize its significance as the endpoint of history at a time when it was only just beginning to establish itself in architecture. But what aim did the critic pursue with this perspective? Put succinctly, Kracauer’s critique of modern architecture can be read as a project of disenchantment. Unlike Max Weber, however, he did not mean by disenchantment the rationalization of premodern traditions and habits. With relish and considerable linguistic artistry, he applied the procedure in question to modernity itself. In doing so, he anticipated many of the points of criticism later gathered under the heading of postmodernism. Through this stance, untimely in a twofold sense, the critic disenchanted the Neues Bauen as an expression of a false rationalism.
Taking Kracauer’s critique of the Werkbund Exhibition as its starting point, the lecture examines the ambivalent relationship of the so-called Frankfurt School to the Neues Bauen. How can the diagnosis of a “false rationalism” be related to Adorno’s expanded concept of functionalism, as well as to Jürgen Habermas’s notion of an “unfinished modernity”? What consequences follow from this for how the Neues Bauen is perceived today?
30 November 2026
4:00 p.m.
State Academy of Fine Arts, Stuttgart